{ "stage": "S2 blocked on ordinary phase1/phase2 control mismatch; no new job or effect", "observed_at": "2026-11-16T20:40:30.6620423Z", "native_read_only": true, "apply_diagnostic": { "code": "TIME_STALE_RESPONSE", "diagnostic_only": true, "helper_pid": 10224, "observed_at_utc": "2026-11-16T20:32:35.053030700Z", "ready": false, "schema_version": 1 }, "current_control": { "agent": { "checkpoint": 10999, "fault": null, "generation": 308, "helper_checkpoint": 422, "last_decision": "7ea5dbda-2b61-4bb2-9c3c-3dbb4037e33a", "pending_request": null }, "helper": { "agent_checkpoint": 10995, "checkpoint": 436, "fault": null, "generation": 308, "last_decision": "7245d5c4-e078-4c76-a55f-d4afbca405ba" }, "requests": [ { "decoded": { "checkpoint": 10999, "helper_checkpoint": 422, "previous_decision_id": "7245d5c4-e078-4c76-a55f-d4afbca405ba", "request_id": "c575c6ea-7cb9-4b44-ae69-1a5729e86714" }, "generation": 308, "request_bytes": 6584, "request_id": "c575c6ea-7cb9-4b44-ae69-1a5729e86714", "response_present": true }, { "decoded": { "checkpoint": 10995, "helper_checkpoint": 421, "previous_decision_id": "7ef63dfd-a683-4369-8b51-f975d71a6275", "request_id": "b0188086-d4e7-4d7a-b01d-c094ee33faa8" }, "generation": 307, "request_bytes": 6584, "request_id": "b0188086-d4e7-4d7a-b01d-c094ee33faa8", "response_present": true } ], "helper_decisions": [ { "checkpoint": 421, "decision_id": "7245d5c4-e078-4c76-a55f-d4afbca405ba", "request_bytes": 6584, "response_bytes": 12917 }, { "checkpoint": 420, "decision_id": "7ef63dfd-a683-4369-8b51-f975d71a6275", "request_bytes": 6584, "response_bytes": 12897 } ] }, "job_states": [ { "attempt_id": "78295f74-4565-459a-87b0-641a8b95feec", "grant_present": false, "job_id": "0a50aae9-a784-4535-b62f-ef24c301d546", "state": "expired" }, { "attempt_id": "ebb387cf-ebb1-4609-a318-32f44d774d11", "grant_present": true, "job_id": "5f1ffef4-2bb6-4c7e-a3a0-fb619144b4f8", "state": "succeeded" }, { "attempt_id": "e2ee25cd-0e23-4c3c-aaa2-3048d232622a", "grant_present": true, "job_id": "645ad11b-9ecd-4efe-8f92-8ad2fb6ed5cf", "state": "succeeded" }, { "attempt_id": "f071e6d6-8635-42f7-92fa-533c681edd8b", "grant_present": true, "job_id": "94047873-5088-433b-bc1b-490d3eafe0da", "state": "failed" } ], "historical221_remains_failed": "failed", "diagnosis": { "failure_before_helper_sqlite_begin": true, "fresh_helper_clock_failed_after_guard_check": "TIME_STALE_RESPONSE", "agent_phase1_committed_before_helper_phase2": true, "old_response_no_longer_applicable": "old capture422 advanced; old decision validity elapsed", "new_administrative_case_created": false, "current_system_scope_activated": false, "new_mcp_system_job_created": false }, "planned_narrow_fix": [ "Read-only proof of one closed-effect partial control edge permits only a fresh ordinary request to the existing server.", "All current independent clock/signature/HelperACK checks remain required; old responses are not applied as current.", "Bounded same-call retry only for typed proven pretransaction clock failure; no effect/Execute retry." ], "limits": [ "Early server-ready was real but does not prove present paired native readiness.", "Current positive SYSTEM qualification was withheld; no stale passive sample used.", "Original history, journals, identity, clock limits and WebUI boundary retained." ] }