From 5771926d66c30a0481fa0c16e7ee338315c1c35e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Kevin Janssen Date: Sun, 15 Nov 2026 10:39:18 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] Record denied native peer quality probe without opening clock gates --- ...erver_time_source_probe_peer_acceptance.py | 393 ++++++++++++++++++ docs/handover.md | 5 + ...erver-time-source-probe-peer-acceptance.md | 118 ++++++ 3 files changed, 516 insertions(+) create mode 100644 deploy/server_time_source_probe_peer_acceptance.py create mode 100644 docs/server-time-source-probe-peer-acceptance.md diff --git a/deploy/server_time_source_probe_peer_acceptance.py b/deploy/server_time_source_probe_peer_acceptance.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d330603 --- /dev/null +++ b/deploy/server_time_source_probe_peer_acceptance.py @@ -0,0 +1,393 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""One fixed source-quality acceptance after the proven peer namespace bootstrap. + +No transport, provisioning, original-phase retry, keys or broker installation. +Run only as the root operator with python3 -I; uncertain execution is read only. +""" +import argparse +import grp +import hashlib +import importlib.util +import json +import os +from pathlib import Path +import stat +import sys +import uuid + +CASE = '5b358997-3abc-43db-945f-f41855b4e3c0' +PHASE = 'probe-peer-acceptance-v1' +PROFILE = 'rmm.server-time-source.peer-acceptance.v1' +PIN_CONTROLLER_SHA = 'fac85dd0399009af36f625232daa5b67ab7fda391dbf95229d4237c307b142ca' +PIN_CONTROLLER = Path('/var/lib/rmm-time-source-operators') / PIN_CONTROLLER_SHA / 'pin_bootstrap.py' +PIN_RESULT_SHA = 'd0a9ac7b46bdf4247c420f01d959c41d6620f7081c40629016d6866828884c4b' +PUBLIC_PIN_SHA = '203f63f150026d345614ca53e641f248397166fbdeb1f28318fc5d7763317e0a' +GROUP_RECEIPT_SHA = '4977876b935bed8903ce4c880a0d9c77c49cd2c7110551fbf854baeccbe64ea7' +OLD_GROUP_PHASE = 'probe-group-acceptance-v1' +OLD_GROUP_CONTROLLER_SHA = 'd04989ccf6d3e7b379a1b02f5fd3ce2545a3563fbce1368f33102f58a36f2dcf' +OLD_GROUP_RESULT_SHA = '96b714e2e43aa13073317c310b213863a02f26dbf2e6c975dc0801ef621eccd5' +OLD_GROUP_LOG_SHA = 'f80644630b09f50fdc731418dbe4f17fff32622910b3efd346a0369b75e985ef' +OLD_GROUP_RECEIPT_SHA = '6923cc1893619f67ae8677b84f9cfea6d0edd554120e9139d843115e52aa7643' +DAC_DIAGNOSTIC_RECEIPT_SHA = 'd999e5260cab3457a7a66603fdb0288615443628e5a28f31df9c1cecd3401ef5' +NAMESPACE_PHASE = 'peer-namespace-bootstrap-v1' +NAMESPACE_CONTROLLER_SHA = '2f1dafece1e5cd1b9be11078edee5f67fbdaef013defa10c527367b42dce9265' +NAMESPACE_CONTROLLER = Path('/var/lib/rmm-time-source-operators') / NAMESPACE_CONTROLLER_SHA / 'peer_namespace_bootstrap.py' +NAMESPACE_RESULT_SHA = 'cb1665cb14086d3ba79089a2eb9e01a532dd779bdcf577eafca0e343b5cc6a8b' +NAMESPACE_LOCAL_SHA = '27e3708a34988fb778cbc8cfd892e0f222b8caf927034e472f391aab65349394' +NAMESPACE_RECEIPT_SHA = '1dc76b5a9673f9e08e59f91f05d586cb9335ffd0a33e697d5170823a6f053619' +NAMESPACE_READ_RECEIPT_SHA = '129584f296b53614e10a9e5eac2bab0a1e70b1c51f7fd70eb31bdf907ce767b3' +OLD_DAC_PHASE = 'probe-dac-acceptance-v1' +OLD_DAC_CONTROLLER_SHA = '1b79a4ab8d587338e43330db0fc73ff2e199dc61f1172da7cc3fc93d3538d2ac' +OLD_DAC_RESULT_SHA = '5f8e0634e44c7caeab2020af5f5dd0d6e83249265d0ebd67f938f0797b551fca' +OLD_DAC_RECEIPT_SHA = '553bc8580deb0e78d780b43c569f3827715a54a7b8629c51c705cf4e9ded7c61' +ARTIFACT = dict(bytes=848632, sha256='216b4d6a0f29ef47576f5ccc469954623141e55d7b43bd73175c1d956363bbbd', elf_machine=183) +BASE = Path('/var/lib/rmm-time-source-bootstrap') / CASE +IMAGE = BASE / 'build/artifacts/operator_probe' +OLD_UNIT = 'rmm-time-source-probe-' + CASE + '.service' +UNIT = 'rmm-time-source-probe-peer-acceptance-' + CASE + '.service' +SAMPLE_KEYS = {'profile', 'clock_authority', 'signed_attestation', 'captured_utc_ns', + 'server_error_ns', 'source_sync_age_ns', 'server_boot_id', + 'captured_monotonic_ns', 'sampled_boottime_ns', 'kernel_state'} + + +def require(ok, reason): + if not ok: + raise RuntimeError(reason) + + +def sha(raw): + return hashlib.sha256(raw).hexdigest() + + +def load_pin_controller(): + # Bootstrap the already reviewed reader without following import paths or + # executing a second, unchecked pathname read. All ancestors stay root-only writable. + parent = os.open('/', os.O_RDONLY | os.O_DIRECTORY | os.O_NOFOLLOW) + try: + for part in PIN_CONTROLLER.parent.parts[1:]: + info = os.fstat(parent) + require(info.st_uid == 0 and info.st_mode & 0o022 == 0, 'protected_controller_ancestry') + child = os.open(part, os.O_RDONLY | os.O_DIRECTORY | os.O_NOFOLLOW, dir_fd=parent) + os.close(parent) + parent = child + info = os.fstat(parent) + require(info.st_uid == 0 and info.st_mode & 0o022 == 0, 'protected_controller_directory') + fd = os.open(PIN_CONTROLLER.name, os.O_RDONLY | os.O_NOFOLLOW, dir_fd=parent) + with os.fdopen(fd, 'rb') as stream: + before = os.fstat(stream.fileno()) + require(stat.S_ISREG(before.st_mode) and before.st_uid == before.st_gid == 0 and + before.st_nlink == 1 and stat.S_IMODE(before.st_mode) == 0o600 and + before.st_size <= 128 * 1024, 'fixed_root_controller_file') + raw = stream.read(128 * 1024 + 1) + stable = lambda item: tuple(getattr(item, 'st_' + key) for key in + ('dev', 'ino', 'uid', 'gid', 'mode', 'nlink', 'size', 'mtime_ns', 'ctime_ns')) + require(stable(before) == stable(os.fstat(stream.fileno())) == + stable(os.stat(PIN_CONTROLLER.name, dir_fd=parent, follow_symlinks=False)) and + len(raw) == before.st_size and + sha(raw) == PIN_CONTROLLER_SHA, 'exact_reviewed_pin_controller') + finally: + os.close(parent) + module = importlib.util.module_from_spec(importlib.util.spec_from_loader('rmm_fixed_pin_reader', loader=None)) + module.__file__ = str(PIN_CONTROLLER) + exec(compile(raw, str(PIN_CONTROLLER), 'exec'), module.__dict__) + held = module.read_file(PIN_CONTROLLER, 128 * 1024) + require(held[0] == raw, 'same_loaded_controller_bytes') + return module, lambda: require(module.read_file(PIN_CONTROLLER, 128 * 1024) == held, + 'pin_controller_unchanged') + + +def group_before_exec(old, log, rows, groups): + require(type(old.get('exit_code')) is int and old['exit_code'] == 216 and log == b'' and + old.get('sample') is None, 'original_216_empty_log_no_sample') + require(groups == [{'gid': 989, 'name': '_chrony', 'present': True}, + {'gid': 10001, 'present': False}], 'actual_original_nss_group_condition') + messages = [row.get('MESSAGE') for row in rows] + require(any(type(text) is str and 'Failed to determine supplementary groups' in text for text in messages) + and any(type(text) is str and 'Failed at step GROUP spawning ' + str(IMAGE) in text for text in messages) + and any(str(row.get('EXIT_STATUS')) == '216' and row.get('EXIT_CODE') == 'exited' for row in rows), + 'original_unit_journal_confirms_pre_exec_group_failure') + + +def failed_group_origin(value, log): + require(value.get('original_case') == CASE and value.get('phase') == OLD_GROUP_PHASE and + value.get('profile') == 'rmm.server-time-source.group-acceptance.v1' and + value.get('controller_sha256') == OLD_GROUP_CONTROLLER_SHA and value.get('artifact') == ARTIFACT and + type(value.get('exit_code')) is int and value['exit_code'] == 1 and value.get('sample') is None and + value.get('source_quality_qualified') is False and value.get('clock_authority') is False and + value.get('signed_attestation') is False and value.get('probe_log_sha256') == sha(log) == OLD_GROUP_LOG_SHA, + 'actual_prior_group_probe_remains_failed_without_source_quality') + + +def namespace_origin(value): + require(value.get('profile') == 'rmm.server-time-source.peer-namespace-bootstrap.v1' and + value.get('phase') == NAMESPACE_PHASE and value.get('original_case') == CASE and + value.get('controller_sha256') == NAMESPACE_CONTROLLER_SHA and + value.get('new_local_profile_sha256') == NAMESPACE_LOCAL_SHA and + value.get('original_main_profile_sha256') == '214e509af9ab9b713e89b09bf6440c4b4248e97c64d4b0d884d2f869d406e1e2' and + value.get('peer_namespace_configured') is True and value.get('apparmor_enforcing') is True and + type(value.get('actual_parser_replace_exit_code')) is int and value['actual_parser_replace_exit_code'] == 0 and + value.get('runtime_boot_chrony_preserved') is True and value.get('source_quality_sampled') is False and + value.get('clock_authority') is False and value.get('signer_created') is False and + value.get('broker_started') is False and value.get('services_restarted') is False, + 'actual_successful_non_quality_peer_namespace_bootstrap') + + +def failed_dac_origin(value, log): + require(value.get('profile') == 'rmm.server-time-source.dac-acceptance.v1' and + value.get('phase') == OLD_DAC_PHASE and value.get('original_case') == CASE and + value.get('controller_sha256') == OLD_DAC_CONTROLLER_SHA and value.get('artifact') == ARTIFACT and + type(value.get('exit_code')) is int and value['exit_code'] == 1 and value.get('sample') is None and + value.get('source_quality_qualified') is False and value.get('clock_authority') is False and + value.get('signed_attestation') is False and value.get('probe_log_sha256') == sha(log) == OLD_GROUP_LOG_SHA, + 'actual_old_dac_failure_never_healed') + + +def sample_quality(sample, boot): + require(type(sample) is dict and set(sample) == SAMPLE_KEYS and + sample['profile'] == 'rmm.native-source-quality.once.v1' and + sample['clock_authority'] is False and sample['signed_attestation'] is False and + sample['server_boot_id'] == boot and str(uuid.UUID(boot)) == boot, + 'exact_non_authoritative_native_sample_schema_and_boot') + for key, upper in (('captured_utc_ns', 2**63 - 1), ('server_error_ns', 500_000_000), + ('source_sync_age_ns', 3_600_000_000_000), ('captured_monotonic_ns', 2**64 - 1), + ('sampled_boottime_ns', 2**64 - 1), ('kernel_state', 4)): + require(type(sample[key]) is int and 0 <= sample[key] <= upper, 'bounded_numeric_quality_sample') + require(sample['captured_utc_ns'] > 0 and sample['captured_monotonic_ns'] > 0 and + sample['sampled_boottime_ns'] >= sample['captured_monotonic_ns'], 'positive_native_time_domains') + + +def probe_args(): + return ['systemd-run', '--quiet', '--wait', '--pipe', '--collect', '--unit=' + UNIT, + '--property=Type=exec', '--property=User=root', '--property=Group=989', + '--property=SupplementaryGroups=', '--property=NoNewPrivileges=yes', + '--property=CapabilityBoundingSet=CAP_SYS_PTRACE CAP_DAC_OVERRIDE', '--property=AmbientCapabilities=', + '--property=ProtectSystem=strict', '--property=ProtectHome=yes', '--property=PrivateTmp=yes', + '--property=PrivateDevices=yes', '--property=RestrictAddressFamilies=AF_UNIX', + '--property=IPAddressDeny=any', + '--property=SystemCallFilter=~@debug ptrace process_vm_readv process_vm_writev', + '--property=RuntimeMaxSec=3s', '--property=ReadWritePaths=/run/rmm-time-source/clients', str(IMAGE)] + + +def host_read(pin): + # No operator import, subprocess, NSS lookup, sockets, preflight or sample. + records = {} + for leaf in ('intent.json', 'before.json', 'group-before-exec.json', 'execution.json', + 'after.json', 'result.json', 'failure.json', 'probe.log'): + try: + raw, proof = pin.read_file(BASE / PHASE / leaf, 16384) + records[leaf] = {'sha256': sha(raw), 'metadata': proof, + 'record': raw.decode('ascii') if leaf == 'probe.log' else pin.parsed(raw)} + except FileNotFoundError: + records[leaf] = None + print(pin.encoded(dict(original_case=CASE, phase=PHASE, read_only=True, records=records)).decode('ascii'), end='') + + +def host_probe(pin, pin_guard): + case_fd = pin.directory(BASE) + phase_fd = -1 + try: + pin.absence(case_fd, PHASE) + operator, operator_guard = pin.load_operator() + original = pin.Original(BASE, operator, operator_guard) + require(original.artifacts['examples/operator_probe'][:2] == (IMAGE, ARTIFACT), 'fixed_original_native_artifact') + pin_raw, pin_proof = pin.read_file(BASE / 'pin/result.json') + require(sha(pin_raw) == PIN_RESULT_SHA, 'actual_original_pin_result') + pin_result = pin.parsed(pin_raw) + old_raw, old_proof = pin.read_file(BASE / 'probe/result.json') + old_log, old_log_proof = pin.read_file(BASE / 'probe/probe.log', 16384) + old = pin.parsed(old_raw) + require(old.get('artifact') == ARTIFACT and old.get('probe_log_sha256') == sha(old_log), + 'original_failed_probe_artifact_and_log') + + group_records = {} + for leaf in ('result.json', 'probe.log', 'before.json', 'after.json'): + group_records[leaf] = pin.read_file(BASE / OLD_GROUP_PHASE / leaf, 16384) + group_raw = group_records['result.json'][0] + require(sha(group_raw) == OLD_GROUP_RESULT_SHA, 'exact_actual_failed_group_probe_result') + previous_group = pin.parsed(group_raw) + failed_group_origin(previous_group, group_records['probe.log'][0]) + require(previous_group['original_probe_result_sha256'] == sha(old_raw) and + previous_group['public_pin_sha256'] == PUBLIC_PIN_SHA and + previous_group['source_tar_sha256'] == original.source_sha and + previous_group['manifest_sha256'] == original.manifest_sha, 'same_original_group_failure_context') + for name in ('before', 'after'): + require(previous_group[name + '_witness'] == dict(filename=name + '.json', + sha256=sha(group_records[name + '.json'][0])), 'actual_prior_group_witness_links') + + ns_raw, ns_proof = pin.read_file(NAMESPACE_CONTROLLER, 128 * 1024) + require(sha(ns_raw) == NAMESPACE_CONTROLLER_SHA, 'exact_namespace_guard_controller') + namespace = importlib.util.module_from_spec(importlib.util.spec_from_loader('rmm_peer_namespace_reader', loader=None)) + namespace.__file__ = str(NAMESPACE_CONTROLLER) + exec(compile(ns_raw, str(NAMESPACE_CONTROLLER), 'exec'), namespace.__dict__) + namespace_records = {'result.json': pin.read_file(BASE / NAMESPACE_PHASE / 'result.json', 16384), + 'original-local-profile.bin': pin.read_file(BASE / NAMESPACE_PHASE / 'original-local-profile.bin', 16384)} + require(sha(namespace_records['result.json'][0]) == NAMESPACE_RESULT_SHA and + namespace_records['original-local-profile.bin'][0] == b'', 'exact_namespace_result_and_old_local_backup') + ns_result = pin.parsed(namespace_records['result.json'][0]) + namespace_origin(ns_result) + require(ns_result['source_tar_sha256'] == original.source_sha and + ns_result['manifest_sha256'] == original.manifest_sha and + ns_result['operator_sha256'] == pin.OPERATOR_SHA and + ns_result['pin_controller_sha256'] == PIN_CONTROLLER_SHA and + ns_result['public_pin_sha256'] == PUBLIC_PIN_SHA, 'same_namespace_original_context') + for name, leaf in (('before', 'before.json'), ('after', 'after.json'), + ('offline_result', 'offline-result.json'), ('reload_result', 'reload-result.json'), + ('acl_applied', 'acl-applied.json')): + namespace_records[leaf] = pin.read_file(BASE / NAMESPACE_PHASE / leaf, 16384) + require(ns_result['records'][name] == dict(filename=leaf, sha256=sha(namespace_records[leaf][0])), + 'actual_namespace_record_hash_link') + ns_after = pin.parsed(namespace_records['after.json'][0]) + require(ns_after['witness']['original'] == original.expected, 'namespace_original_runtime_boot_chrony_generation') + main_profile = pin.read_file(namespace.MAIN, 65536, 0o644) + local_profile = pin.read_file(namespace.LOCAL, 16384, 0o644) + require(sha(main_profile[0]) == namespace.MAIN_SHA and sha(local_profile[0]) == NAMESPACE_LOCAL_SHA and + local_profile[0] == namespace.LOCAL_BYTES and local_profile[1] == ns_after['new_local_metadata'], + 'actual_held_main_and_namespace_local_profile') + dac_records = {leaf: pin.read_file(BASE / OLD_DAC_PHASE / leaf, 16384) + for leaf in ('result.json', 'probe.log', 'before.json', 'after.json')} + require(sha(dac_records['result.json'][0]) == OLD_DAC_RESULT_SHA, 'exact_actual_failed_dac_result') + old_dac = pin.parsed(dac_records['result.json'][0]) + failed_dac_origin(old_dac, dac_records['probe.log'][0]) + for name in ('before', 'after'): + require(old_dac[name + '_witness'] == dict(filename=name + '.json', + sha256=sha(dac_records[name + '.json'][0])), 'actual_old_dac_witness_links') + + def fresh(): + pin_guard() + actual_pin = original.fresh() + require(pin.read_file(NAMESPACE_CONTROLLER, 128 * 1024) == (ns_raw, ns_proof), 'namespace_guard_controller_unchanged') + for phase_name, records in ((NAMESPACE_PHASE, namespace_records), (OLD_DAC_PHASE, dac_records)): + for leaf, retained in records.items(): + require(pin.read_file(BASE / phase_name / leaf, 16384) == retained, 'namespace_and_failed_dac_records_unchanged') + require(pin.read_file(namespace.MAIN, 65536, 0o644) == main_profile and + pin.read_file(namespace.LOCAL, 16384, 0o644) == local_profile, 'held_main_local_profiles_unchanged') + parent = pin.directory(namespace.PARENT) + try: + require(namespace.acl(parent) == namespace.expected_acl() and + namespace.acl(parent, 'system.posix_acl_default') is None, 'actual_exact_peer_parent_acl') + finally: + os.close(parent) + current_profile = namespace.profile_state(actual_pin['daemon_pid']) + for leaf, retained in group_records.items(): + require(pin.read_file(BASE / OLD_GROUP_PHASE / leaf, 16384) == retained, + 'original_failed_group_records_unchanged') + require(pin.read_file(BASE / 'pin/result.json') == (pin_raw, pin_proof) and + pin.read_file(BASE / 'probe/result.json') == (old_raw, old_proof) and + pin.read_file(BASE / 'probe/probe.log', 16384) == (old_log, old_log_proof), + 'original_pin_and_failed_probe_records_unchanged') + raw, proof = pin.read_file(pin.ETC / 'chrony-pin.json', 8192) + require(sha(raw) == PUBLIC_PIN_SHA == pin_result['public_pin_sha256'] and + raw == pin.encoded(actual_pin) and proof == pin_result['public_pin_metadata'], + 'actual_unchanged_public_pin_and_original_metadata') + dirs = {} + for path in (pin.ETC, pin.RUN, pin.RUN / 'clients'): + fd = pin.directory(path) + try: + current = pin.stable_directory(os.fstat(fd)) + finally: + os.close(fd) + recorded = pin_result['targets'][str(path)] + require(current == {key: recorded[key] for key in current}, 'original_runtime_directory_identity') + dirs[str(path)] = current + return dict(observation=original.expected, public_pin_sha256=PUBLIC_PIN_SHA, + public_pin_metadata=proof, target_directories=dirs, + peer_namespace=dict(result_sha256=NAMESPACE_RESULT_SHA, + main_profile_sha256=namespace.MAIN_SHA, local_profile_sha256=NAMESPACE_LOCAL_SHA, + main_profile_metadata=main_profile[1], local_profile_metadata=local_profile[1], + parent_access_acl_hex=namespace.expected_acl().hex(), profile=current_profile)) + + before = fresh() + os.mkdir(PHASE, mode=0o700, dir_fd=case_fd) + os.fsync(case_fd) + phase_fd = os.open(PHASE, os.O_RDONLY | os.O_DIRECTORY | os.O_NOFOLLOW, dir_fd=case_fd) + own_raw, _ = pin.read_file(Path(__file__).absolute(), 128 * 1024) + binding = dict(profile=PROFILE, original_case=CASE, phase=PHASE, unit=UNIT, + controller_sha256=sha(own_raw), operator_sha256=pin.OPERATOR_SHA, + pin_controller_sha256=PIN_CONTROLLER_SHA, public_pin_sha256=PUBLIC_PIN_SHA, + source_tar_sha256=original.source_sha, manifest_sha256=original.manifest_sha, + artifact=ARTIFACT, original_group_receipt_sha256=GROUP_RECEIPT_SHA, + original_probe_result_sha256=sha(old_raw), pin_result_sha256=PIN_RESULT_SHA, + original_group_acceptance_controller_sha256=OLD_GROUP_CONTROLLER_SHA, + original_group_acceptance_result_sha256=OLD_GROUP_RESULT_SHA, + original_group_acceptance_log_sha256=OLD_GROUP_LOG_SHA, + original_group_acceptance_receipt_sha256=OLD_GROUP_RECEIPT_SHA, + original_dac_diagnostic_receipt_sha256=DAC_DIAGNOSTIC_RECEIPT_SHA, + peer_namespace_controller_sha256=NAMESPACE_CONTROLLER_SHA, + peer_namespace_result_sha256=NAMESPACE_RESULT_SHA, + peer_namespace_local_profile_sha256=NAMESPACE_LOCAL_SHA, + peer_namespace_receipt_sha256=NAMESPACE_RECEIPT_SHA, + peer_namespace_read_receipt_sha256=NAMESPACE_READ_RECEIPT_SHA, + original_dac_acceptance_controller_sha256=OLD_DAC_CONTROLLER_SHA, + original_dac_acceptance_result_sha256=OLD_DAC_RESULT_SHA, + original_dac_acceptance_log_sha256=OLD_GROUP_LOG_SHA, + original_dac_acceptance_receipt_sha256=OLD_DAC_RECEIPT_SHA) + pin.exclusive(phase_fd, 'intent.json', pin.encoded(dict(binding, once=True, no_retry=True))) + groups = [] + for gid in (989, 10001): + try: + group = grp.getgrgid(gid) + groups.append(dict(gid=gid, name=group.gr_name, present=True)) + except KeyError: + groups.append(dict(gid=gid, present=False)) + boot = original.expected['boot_id'] + rows_raw = operator.run(['journalctl', '--unit=' + OLD_UNIT, '--boot=' + uuid.UUID(boot).hex, + '--no-pager', '-n', '12', '-o', 'json'], timeout=10, limit=65536) + rows = [pin.parsed(row) for row in rows_raw.splitlines()] + group_before_exec(old, old_log, rows, groups) + pin.exclusive(phase_fd, 'group-before-exec.json', pin.encoded(dict( + unit=OLD_UNIT, boot_id=boot, original_receipt_sha256=GROUP_RECEIPT_SHA, + original_probe_result_sha256=sha(old_raw), group_resolution=groups, + journal_sha256=sha(rows_raw), pre_exec_group_failure=True))) + pin.exclusive(phase_fd, 'before.json', pin.encoded(dict(binding, witness=before))) + fresh() # Last source/runtime/pin guard before the single executable action. + code = operator.long_command(probe_args(), BASE / PHASE / 'probe.log', 10) + log_raw, _ = pin.read_file(BASE / PHASE / 'probe.log', 16384) + execution = dict(binding, exit_code=code, probe_log_sha256=sha(log_raw)) + pin.exclusive(phase_fd, 'execution.json', pin.encoded(execution)) + after = fresh() + require(before == after, 'all_original_runtime_boot_pin_source_witnesses_preserved') + pin.exclusive(phase_fd, 'after.json', pin.encoded(dict(binding, witness=after))) + sample = pin.parsed(log_raw) if code == 0 else None + if code == 0: + sample_quality(sample, boot) + links = {} + for name in ('before', 'after'): + raw, _ = pin.read_file(BASE / PHASE / (name + '.json'), 16384) + links[name + '_witness'] = dict(filename=name + '.json', sha256=sha(raw)) + result = dict(binding, **links, exit_code=code, sample=sample, probe_log_sha256=sha(log_raw), + source_quality_qualified=code == 0, runtime_boot_pin_source_preserved=True, + clock_authority=False, signed_attestation=False, signer_created=False, + broker_started=False, http_deployed=False) + pin.exclusive(phase_fd, 'result.json', pin.encoded(result)) + print(pin.encoded(result).decode('ascii'), end='') + except Exception as error: + if phase_fd >= 0: + pin.exclusive(phase_fd, 'failure.json', pin.encoded(dict(profile=PROFILE, original_case=CASE, + failed=True, exception_type=type(error).__name__, read_original_phase_only=True))) + raise + finally: + if phase_fd >= 0: + os.close(phase_fd) + os.close(case_fd) + + +def main(): + parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__) + parser.add_argument('command', choices=('host-probe', 'host-read')) + args = parser.parse_args() + require(sys.flags.isolated == 1 and os.geteuid() == 0 and os.uname().sysname == 'Linux' and + os.uname().machine == 'aarch64', 'isolated_root_linux_aarch64_only') + os.umask(0o077) + pin, guard = load_pin_controller() + if args.command == 'host-read': + host_read(pin) + else: + host_probe(pin, guard) + + +if __name__ == '__main__': + try: + main() + except Exception: + print(json.dumps(dict(failed=True, read_original_phase_only=True)), flush=True) + raise SystemExit(1) diff --git a/docs/handover.md b/docs/handover.md index 335cad2..a9624c9 100644 --- a/docs/handover.md +++ b/docs/handover.md @@ -1,5 +1,10 @@ # Übergabe — Linux-MVP abgeschlossen, Windows wird fortgesetzt +**Reale Peer-Zeitqualitätsprobe fehlgeschlagen:** neuer Fallteilf37040c5, +Exit1/kein Sample; separater Read bestätigt unveränderte Runtime-/Chronyzeugen. +[Ergebnis](server-time-source-probe-peer-acceptance.md). Namespace bleibt +konfiguriert und Enforce; Broker-/Windowsclock-/Jobgates weiter geschlossen. + **Namespacebootstrap auf dem permanenten Server bestanden:** exakte Such-ACL und enger Chrony-Localoverride eingerichtet, tatsächlicher Parser-Replace0 und separater Read belegt; Enforce, Chronyprozess, Boot und RMM-Runtime erhalten. diff --git a/docs/server-time-source-probe-peer-acceptance.md b/docs/server-time-source-probe-peer-acceptance.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..51961a0 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/server-time-source-probe-peer-acceptance.md @@ -0,0 +1,118 @@ +# Einmalige reale Sourceprobe nach tatsächlicher Peer-Namespacefreigabe + +`deploy/server_time_source_probe_peer_acceptance.py` besitzt genau die neue +Phase `probe-peer-acceptance-v1` im erhaltenen Originalfall +`5b358997-3abc-43db-945f-f41855b4e3c0`. Keine alte Probe wird erneut ausgeführt, +umgeschrieben oder erfolgreich umgedeutet. Der tatsächliche Namespacebootstrap +2f1dafece war erfolgreich; das ist noch kein Source-Sample. + +Sein Originalresult-SHA256 ist +`cb1665cb14086d3ba79089a2eb9e01a532dd779bdcf577eafca0e343b5cc6a8b`, +Rootreceipt1dc76b5a und separater Readreceipt +`129584f296b53614e10a9e5eac2bab0a1e70b1c51f7fd70eb31bdf907ce767b3`. +Der Qualifier verlangt diesen tatsächlich erfolgreichen Rootrecord samt allen +gehashten Before-/After-/Offline-/ACL-/Reloadrecords und unverändertem privaten +Leeroverride-Altbackup. Der geschützte Namespacecontroller wird ausschließlich +aus exakt gehashten Root600-Bytes geladen, ohne dessen mutierenden Pfad aufzurufen. + +## Unveränderte Probe, frische Namespaceguards + +Das ursprüngliche Root500-/Singlelink-ELF bleibt848632Bytes, +SHA256`216b4d6a0f29ef47576f5ccc469954623141e55d7b43bd73175c1d956363bbbd`, +ELF64/AArch64-Machine183. Providerquelle3fd9, fac85-/ecb72-Originalguards, +öffentlicher Pin203f63, Pinresultd0a9 und komplette ursprüngliche Source-/Boot-/ +Chronyprozess-/Runtimebindung bleiben unverändert. Vor/nach werden zusätzlich +Root644-Singlelink-Mainprofil214e509a und neues Localprofil +`27e3708a34988fb778cbc8cfd892e0f222b8caf927034e472f391aab65349394` +auf gehaltene Originalbytes/Metadaten geprüft. Der Parent muss exakt die +erwartete benannte989--x/Mask--x-ACL ohne Default-ACL besitzen; sein originaler +Owner, GID, Modus und Inode bleiben unverändert. Das aktuelle Chrony-Kernelprofil +muss weiterhin `/usr/sbin/chronyd (enforce)` sein. + +Gegenüber dem vorherigen DAC-Qualifier1b79 ändern sich im Execvektor ausschließlich +eigene Unit/Phase, keine Härtung oder Capability: Root/GID989, leere Zusatzgruppen, +BoundingSet CAP_SYS_PTRACE+CAP_DAC_OVERRIDE, NNP, ProtectSystem=strict, ProtectHome, +PrivateTmp/Devices, AF_UNIX-only/IP-deny, Debug-/ptrace-/process_vm-Syscalldeny, +RuntimeMaxSec3s/äußerer10s-Wächter und Schreiben nur in vorhandene Chronyclients. +Neue Unit: +`rmm-time-source-probe-peer-acceptance-5b358997-3abc-43db-945f-f41855b4e3c0.service`. +Ein eigener create-only/fsync-Intent steht vor genau einem Exec. Kein MAC-/ACL- +Ändern, Signer, Schlüssel oder RMM-Job. Vorhandene Phase oder unklare Antwort +erlaubt ausschließlich Lesen, kein Resume/Retry. Gruppe10001 muss weiterhin +abwesend sein; diese Qualityprobe kommt vor späterem Broker-Gruppenbootstrap. + +## Ergebnis und alte Fehler + +Das alte DAC-Result ist strikt auf Exit1/kein Sample/qualityfalse gebunden: +SHA256`5f8e0634e44c7caeab2020af5f5dd0d6e83249265d0ebd67f938f0797b551fca`, +Logf8064463, ursprünglicher Controller1b79 und Rootreceipt553bc858. Es und +seine beiden Witnessdateien werden vor/nach unverändert gehalten. Die noch +älteren GROUP-/VorExecbelege bleiben ebenso gebunden. Ein neuer Erfolg wäre +ausschließlich ein neuer tatsächlicher Beleg dieser Peerphase. + +Ergebnis nur unter +`/var/lib/rmm-time-source-bootstrap/5b358997-3abc-43db-945f-f41855b4e3c0/probe-peer-acceptance-v1/result.json`, +Profil `rmm.server-time-source.peer-acceptance.v1`. Das bisherige geschlossene +Sample-/Exit-/Before-/After-Schema bleibt gleich: genau ein NativeTimeSource- +Sample bei Erfolg, Boot exakt Originalboot, echte begrenzte Integer, Gesamtfehler +höchstens500ms, Syncalter höchstens1h, Kernelstate0..4. Nur Exit0 mit vollständig +validiertem Sample und erhaltenen Zeugen erlaubt `source_quality_qualified=true`. +`clock_authority=false` und `signed_attestation=false` bleiben fest. + +Zusätzlich zu den bisherigen19 Bindingfeldern werden überall exakt diese neun +Herkunftsbindungen gespeichert: +`peer_namespace_controller_sha256`, `peer_namespace_result_sha256`, +`peer_namespace_local_profile_sha256`, `peer_namespace_receipt_sha256`, +`peer_namespace_read_receipt_sha256`, `original_dac_acceptance_controller_sha256`, +`original_dac_acceptance_result_sha256`, `original_dac_acceptance_log_sha256`, +`original_dac_acceptance_receipt_sha256`. +Der vorhandene Witness erhält zusätzlich `peer_namespace`: Result-/Main-/ +Localhash, gehaltene Main-/Localmetadaten, exaktes Parent-ACL-Hex und aktuellen +Enforceprofilbeleg. Jeder Before-/After-Record bleibt per Name/SHA im Ergebnis +gebunden. Ein Broker-Qualitygate darf ausschließlich das tatsächliche neue +Peerresult prüfen; alle alten false-Ergebnisse bleiben false. + +Geplant, durch diese Implementierung **nicht ausgeführt**: + +```text +python3 -I /reviewter/geschuetzter/pfad/probe_peer_acceptance.py host-probe +python3 -I /reviewter/geschuetzter/pfad/probe_peer_acceptance.py host-read +``` + +Der Read liest nur eigene vorhandene Records/Logs; kein NSS/Preflight/Socket/ +Reload oder erneutes Sampling. Roottransport, unabhängiger Quellenreview und +tatsächliches natives Sample bleiben separate Rootabnahmeschritte. Windows- +Clock-/Jobgates und jeder WebUI-genehmigte RMM-Plan bleiben davon getrennt. + +## Tatsächlich lokal geprüft + +Controller-SHA256 +`ca89eac44d6b1e8bbbb14cca58ecabb02fd05d59292b77f703997fad0c29e3c8`. +Privater Fall `6fdd3d67-8608-49db-9735-0b68e49a773c`: AST und zwei gezielte +reine Fixturefälle bestanden. Der Execvektor ist gegenüber dem tatsächlichen +DAC-Qualifier bis auf die eigene Unit exakt gleich. Das gespeicherte tatsächliche +Namespace-Ergebnis wurde positiv geprüft; falsches Enforce, Replace-Exit und +Localhash wurden verweigert. Der tatsächliche alte DAC-Exit1 wurde als Origin +akzeptiert, umgeschriebenes qualitytrue/Exit0 verweigert. Receipt-SHA256 +`88d059d7af5fa40ca124c2781866393d1f1d58c0d6567a15568cf58fb8ad4915`. +Sie bindet die Dokumentfassung vor diesem Ergebnisnachtrag. Keine Builds, +Kernel-/NSS-/Zeitgetter, Probe-, Parser-, SSH- oder Zielaktionen ausgeführt. +Unabhängiger Review und der neue tatsächliche native Sample stehen noch aus. + +## Tatsächliche Cloud-Abnahme 2026-11-15: fehlgeschlagen + +Nach unabhängigem Quellenreview wurde diese neue Phase genau einmal auf dem +permanenten Server ausgeführt. Rootcallf37040c5, Receipt +`c10e40296991f2075953782eca737764e872596e379934630aea918f192a4c13`. +Tatsächlicher Probe-Exit1, kein Sample, `source_quality_qualified=false`; +Loghashf8064463 bleibt die generische Providerverweigerung. Namespaceguards +und Before/After-Witnesses sind identisch (beidee16a55a1). Kein Signer, Broker +oder HTTP-/Windows-Jobgate wurde aktiviert. + +Separater ausschließlich lesender Rückabruf c4acb44e, Receipt +`a4df17e5160687a97e34f4c9f376c2a5dacfed6cedb7d39e0875e0df3e429aac`, +bestätigt Originalresult +`71f212c5886b786f98d3dbe39f8a0adf76769e4f66ee516476db7df31cda413c` +und unveränderte Zeugen. Der erfolgreich eingerichtete Namespace allein hat +damit die reale Providerverweigerung noch nicht beseitigt. Keine Wiederholung +dieser Phase; eine getrennte Diagnose soll den verbleibenden Fehler benennen.